A New York appellate panel upheld a Manhattan jury’s findings of first-degree assault and attempted second-degree assault, along with an aggregate eight-year sentence. The opinion turns on three pillars: medical testimony establishing “serious physical injury,” limits on using a defendant’s recorded statement at trial, and why a phone left unattended…
In a recent New York Assault case, the First Department’s decision in People v Manley addresses a common voir dire scenario: a prospective juror relays information to a court officer, the officer communicates it to the judge, and the judge decides how to proceed. The court held that such a relay…
If you are facing charges in New York involving allegations of hate crimes, you need to understand how courts review these cases on appeal. In a recent decision from the Appellate Division, Second Department, the court affirmed a conviction for assault in the first degree as a hate crime after…
In People v. Williams (2025 NY Slip Op 03603), the Appellate Division held that a man convicted after pleading guilty to first-degree assault and attempted robbery was wrongfully arrested and that prosecutors lacked probable cause to justify the detention. As a result, the court not only suppressed all evidence obtained…
If you are facing a serious charge like assault in New York, your right to a fair trial includes more than just a competent defense—it includes how the jury is instructed on evaluating eyewitness testimony. In People v. Salas, the New York Court of Appeals tackled a defendant’s argument that…
In People v. Bacon, the New York Court of Appeals reaffirmed a long-standing rule: if your defense lawyer fails to raise a specific constitutional objection during trial, you may lose the ability to argue that issue on appeal. This decision is a clear warning to anyone charged with a serious…
If you’re a survivor of domestic violence and serving time for a crime you committed while in an abusive relationship, you may be wondering whether New York law allows you to be resentenced based on your trauma. Under Criminal Procedure Law § 440.47, the Domestic Violence Survivors Justice Act (DVSJA)…
Recently a juvenile who was adjudicated a Juvenile Delinquent in Family Court recently won an appeal. When a victim or witness makes an identification after a crime, the identification must be both credible and consistent. A recent case before the Supreme Court of the State of New York, Appellate Division,…
When an individual is charged with assault, the proceedings can take many different forms. It can depend, in part, on what kind of assault the State alleges the defendant committed. In an opinion that recently came out of an appeals court in New York, the court discusses the difference between…
In a procedurally complex case, the New York Court of Appeals recently issued a decision reversing an appellate court’s decision in favor of the criminal defendant. The defendant originally faced charges after he broke into a college dormitory, supposedly attempting to sexually assault girls in the dormitory. At trial, the…