New York Criminal Attorney Blog
In a recent New York gun case, the Court upheld a warrantless search of a defendant’s bag. Under New York law, when a police officer does not have prior approval from a judge, the officer is still allowed to search and seize a person’s private property under certain limited circumstances. One of these situations is when the officer has a reasonable basis to believe that there is an emergency, and that a search or seizure is necessary to quickly protect the public from harm. Courts can vary on what it means for an officer to have this “reasonable basis” to believe an emergency exists.
Case Before New York Court
In a recent case before the Supreme Court of New York, First Department, the defendant argued that a police officer unreasonably searched his personal bag. The officer had found a weapon in the bag, and the defendant later faced charges for and a conviction of criminal possession of a weapon. The defendant’s argument on appeal centered on the fact that the officer did not have a basis to search his private property, given that he had not given the officer permission and that the officer had not obtained a warrant from a judge. The search, argued the defendant, was therefore unreasonable and an infringement on his constitutional rights under the Fourth Amendment.
The Emergency Doctrine
The court disagreed with the defendant, ruling instead that the officer could indeed search the defendant’s bag under New York’s emergency doctrine. There were several reasons the officer had a “reasonable basis” to believe there was an emergency: the officer was responding to a nearby radio call indicating a suspect matching the defendant’s description had a gun; a woman nearby was yelling that the defendant had a gun; and the defendant fled the scene when the officer approached.
Because of the circumstances at play, the court decided that the officer did, in fact, have the authority to search the defendant’s property. This emergency doctrine can be tricky, and if you have questions about whether a police officer invaded your rights under the guise of this doctrine, contact a New York firearms attorney that can inform you of your rights and help you figure out how to aggressively fight for them.
Do You or a Loved One Need a New York Firearms Attorney by Your Side?
At Tilem & Associates, we take your charges seriously because we understand how much is on the line when your freedom is at stake. If you are looking for a relentless, experienced group of attorneys to fight your charges, we are the group for you. Our team is committed to putting the client’s needs first, and we use this client-centered approach to inform our litigation strategy in every case we take on.
For a free and confidential consultation with a New York firearms attorney at Tilem & Associates, give us a call as soon as possible to discuss your case at 877-377-8666. You can also fill out our online form to tell us about your case and have a member of our team reach back out as soon as possible regarding next steps.